Sigh, Robin Roberts Could Have Won Cy Youngs


Robin Roberts won 138 games  between 1950 and 1955 for the Phillies.

Robin Roberts won 138 games for the  Phillies from 1950-55.

By Glen Sparks

Robin Roberts’ peak years just missed the Cy Young Award era. If Baseball had started giving out the award in 1950, Roberts may have taken home a couple.

The Philadelphia Phillies’ right-hander pitched on seven All-Star teams and won at least 20 games six straight years. Roberts played on his last All-Star team in 1956, the inaugural season for the Cy Young Award. (Who won the first Cy Young Award? Remember that the award was given to just one pitcher until 1967.) Actually, that was kind of a dull year for the Phillies’ ace. He finished with a 19-18 record and a 4.45 ERA (83 ERA+).

From 1950 through 1955, Roberts was as good as anybody. He won 138 games, accumulated 46.4 WAR points and finished first in WAR for pitchers every year between 1950 and 1954. (Warren Spahn of the Boston/Milwaukee Braves was the runner-up every season except ‘54. That year, he was fourth.) He led the National League in wins four straight years (1952-55).

The case for Roberts as the premier pitcher throughout much of the ‘50s only gets better. He was first in games started six straight times (1950-55) innings pitched five straight times (1951-55), complete games five straight times (1952-56) and strikeouts two straight times (1953-54).

Yes, he gave up lots of  home runs (Pitching his home games at Shibe Park didn’t help.), but he didn’t walk anyone. Roberts could pitch and put the ball on the black. Batters didn’t just worry about Roberts’ blazing fastball. They also worried about his curveball and change-up.

If you could go back and vote for N.L. Cy Young awards during Roberts’ prime, it might go like this:

1950 – Roberts or Jim Konstanty, Roberts’ teammate (Konstanty, a reliever, won the MVP.)

1951 – The Giants’ Sal Maglie

1952 – Roberts easily

1953 – Probably Spahn, maybe Roberts

1954 – The Giants’ Johnny Antonelli

1955 – Roberts, Spahn and the Pittsburg Pirates’ Bob Friend battle it out.



Roberts won 28 games in 1952.

Roberts won 28 games in 1952.

Anyway, Roberts is in the mix every year. If you just give out one award for both leagues, the N.L. guy most likely gets the nod in every case except, maybe, one. Philadelphia A’s lefty Bobby Shantz, all 5-feet-6-inches, 139 pounds of him, put together a huge year in 1952. Good enough to beat Roberts?

You make the call:

Shantz: 24-7, .774 W-L percentage, 2.48 ERA, 159 ERA+, 279.2 IP, 152 strikeouts, 27 CG, five shutouts, 1.048 WHIP, 9.1 WAR.

Roberts: 28-7, .800 W-L percentage, 2.59, 141 ERA+, 330 IP, 148 strikeouts, 30 CG, three shutouts, 1.021, 8.3 WAR.

Oh, and Shantz won the A.L. MVP. Roberts finished second in the N.L. This one could go either way. It was certainly Shantz’s best season in the big leagues. He accumulated almost half his career WAR points (32.1) in 1952. Well, it would have a great debate in Philly sports writing circles. … Interesting. Maybe Roberts gets four Cy Youngs. Maybe he gets shut out. It depends on what stats you prefer, how you look at ’52 and if you give out just one award or one award for each league.

Ralph Berger wrote a lengthy article about Roberts as part of the Society for American Baseball Research (SABR) biography project. Berger quotes a line that Hugh Brown wrote in a Sport magazine feature on the Springfield, Ill., native. First off, it might be good to know that Roberts earned a bachelor’s degree from Michigan State University and served in the Army Air Corps training program during World War II. He was president of the Gold King Seafood Company in Philadelphia even as a player.

“As athletes go,” Brown writes, “Roberts can safely be called one of the more complex. In conversation, he is at least two IQ notches above most of his compatriots, yet he admits that his intellectual interests are confined mostly to television when he is home and Western movies when he is on the road.”

Roberts pitched nearly three seasons with the Orioles.

Roberts pitched nearly three full seasons with the Orioles.

Following a few down years, Roberts enjoyed a solid 1958 season (17-14, 3.24, 6.2 WAR). The Phillies traded their former ace to the Baltimore Orioles after the 1961 campaign. He had a few good years in the American League, went to the Houston Astros and finished up with the Chicago Cubs. His career record was 286-245.

Baseball Writers voted Roberts into the Hall of Fame in 1976. He died in 2010 in Florida. Roberts would have been 88 today. Happy Birthday to one of baseball’s most overlooked pitchers.


Robin Roberts trivia:

Jamie Moyer gave up the most career home runs to batters (522). Roberts is second (502), followed By Ferguson Jenkins (484), Phil Niekro (482) and Don Sutton (472). Moyer is the only one in the top five not in the Hall of Fame.

Roberts is the only pitcher to beat the Braves in all three cities they have been based: Boston, Milwaukee and Atlanta.

Roberts went to Michigan State on a basketball scholarship. While with the Phillies, he organized the Robin Roberts All-Stars basketball team. The squad played the Harlem Globetrotters, among other teams.

*The Brooklyn Dodgers’ Don Newcombe won the first Cy Young Award. He went 27-7 in 1956 with a 3.06 ERA (131 ERA+).

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s